From Decision to Doing: How Do We Turn Collective Energy Into Collective Action?

Yesterday on Collective Contribution TV, we were talking about collective decisioning. And an interesting turn of the conversation was that the challenge lay not in MAKING the decision, but in what happens next.

How do we move a decision into empowered action ACROSS the team?

Since I love me a good science connection, I thought it would be worth exploring how the energy of a decision made can be converted into the doing that brings that decision to life. Because, let's all be honest, so many decisions, especially in business, don't end up making any kind of measurable impact.

Let's go!

The Decision Symphony

One of the concepts that came up during the conversation was around "Decision Bundles"; the concept of which is that no one decision stands alone, but interacts with other decisions at various times at various points on the timeline.

Add that to the concept of a "Decision Symphony" (a consistent rhythm for decision-making, that can become muscle memory within an organization), and a visual starts to appear...

An orchestra.

We have groups of notes (our decision bundles), being played by groups of instruments (our teams), and they either sound good (a symphony), or like an eighth-grade band (I've been in one and it does NOT sound great most of the time🤣)

And this is precisely where we go to work.

When the musical notes are all connected in symphony, the energy flows. It flows between the notes, between the teams, and out into the wider world.

But when the trumpets are at odds with the french horns, or the flutes have jumped ahead because they're tired of waiting, the flow stops. And slowly the energy dissipates from the collective, and encourages people to STOP instead of to keep moving.

And that begs the next question...

Where Does the Energy Go?

Let's talk about physics, shall we? Remember that nagging bit of information we learned at some point in school about how energy is neither created nor destroyed? Now, even if human energy doesn't work quite like physical energy, the energy of a decision doesn't just disappear. So, where DOES it go?

Let's look at what can happen on the timeline.

A decision gets made. Let's say, everyone's actually really excited about it. And then, the team runs into an unpredicted client issue, and needs to spend time fixing that. Oh, and all those daily and weekly tasks that need to get done? Those things need to happen too. And all those things take energy. So, if energy is neither created nor destroyed, the energy to do those things that come AFTER the decision on the timeline? They end up using the energy from that decision instead of the decision powering something different.

Who else has observed exactly that?

We make a decision. We run a change management announcement to the team. And everyone just silently goes back to what they were doing before.

Which brings up another scientific principle: momentum.

You see, people are always acting on momentum; the momentum of their current behavior. And any decision, especially one that changes directions at all, requires us to consider what needs to STOP (what we're going to stop doing to make room for the new decision) and what needs to START (what we're going to start doing to get it going). And as I'm writing this, I'm actually wondering if that's the piece of the puzzle that's missing.

If we think about it, every decision that requires change is actually competing with the momentum of everything that's already happening.

And we tend to spend an awful lot of time talking about what we're going to start doing, without spending nearly as much time considering what we're going to stop doing to make room for it.

Something's gotta give. And if we don't consciously decide what that something is, we leave it up to individuals to figure out for themselves. Which means the decision we made collectively ends up competing with all the decisions people are making individually about where to spend their time and energy. And our symphony starts to fall apart.

Oh, now we're on to something.

The Physics of Changing Direction

Shall we bring another principle from physics to the table? Let's talk about inertia.

An object in motion tends to stay in motion unless acted upon by an outside force.

And while people aren't objects, our existing behaviours have a certain amount of inertia. Routines. Responsibilities. Commitments. Documentation. Reports. Standing Meetings. Process Expectations. And all those things have already found their places in our days.

When we introduce that new decision, particularly if it requires us to do something differently, we're not starting from zero. We need to change the direction of something that's already moving. And changing direction requires an intervention.

But the decision itself is NOT the intervention (as I think we can all see). It's only the agreement that an intervention needs to happen.

Think about that for a second.

We can collectively decide to change direction without actually changing anything about how we're moving. And if nothing changes about how we're moving, why would we expect to end up somewhere different?

What Are We Willing to Stop?

Let's go back to our orchestra.

Imagine the conductor announces that we're going to play a completely different piece of music. Everyone agrees. They're excited about the new piece. They can imagine how wonderful it's going to sound. But when the conductor raises the baton...

Everyone just keeps playing the old song.

Not because they're trying to be difficult. Not because they don't believe in the new music. But because nobody actually told them when to stop playing the old piece, how to transition, or where their part in the new one begins.

And maybe that's what we're missing in so many of our organizational decisions.

We tell people what we've decided. We tell them WHY we've decided it. We might even tell them what success is supposed to look like. But do we actually create the conditions for them to DO something differently?

  • Do we remove competing priorities?

  • Do we change expectations?

  • Do we make room for the learning that inevitably comes with doing something new?

Or do we just add another thing to the list and hope everyone figures it out?

I suspect we do an awful lot of that last one.

The Difference Between Agreement and Commitment

When we make a decision together, it's tempting to assume that everyone who agrees with the decision is also committed to making it happen. But that's not necessarily true.

I can agree that something is a good idea without having the capacity to contribute to it.

I can believe in the direction without understanding what my role is in getting there.

And I can be genuinely excited about an outcome while still feeling responsible for a whole bunch of other things that aren't going away.

Which makes me wonder if we're forgetting to ask an important question that connects the decision to the doing...

"What will each of us do differently because of this decision?"

And maybe, even more importantly:

"What will each of us STOP doing to make this possible?"

And equally important:

"What do I need from my team members to enable this for me?"

These types of questions start to move us beyond agreement and into contribution. They create an opportunity for people to identify what they can actually own, what they need from others, and what might prevent them from following through.

And they give the collective a chance to see the whole picture before everyone heads back to their individual instruments.

From Decision-Making to Decision-Moving

One of the ideas that emerged after the live conversation was about developing a consistent rhythm for decisions. A repeatable process that could eventually become muscle memory. But if the challenge in your organization doesn't seem to be making the decision, but getting it implemented, we actually need a different focus.

Instead of focusing on the decision-MAKING (Problem 1), we can create a rhythm of decision-MOVING (Problem 2) 🎉

Not necessarily another methodology, or another set of steps everyone has to follow. But a collective expectation that a decision isn't complete until we've understood what needs to change to bring it to life.

What stops? What starts? And not only who owns the movement, but how everyone contributes? And let's not forget to define how we'll know whether we're actually moving.

Everyone's process - or set of notes they're playing - might be different. But if our rhythm is showing movement towards our goals, now we're going somewhere.

The Real Opportunity

If we go all the way back to our original question about energy, perhaps we've been looking at this backwards.

We've been trying to figure out how to create enough energy to bring our decisions to life, when the energy is already there. It's just being used to power everything we're already doing.

And if we want to use that energy to create something different, we have to be willing to redirect it.

Not just individually. Collectively.

Because if I stop playing my old notes, but the rest of the orchestra keeps playing the old song, we're not going to create much of a symphony. And if everyone starts playing the new song without understanding how their contributions connect, we're probably going to create a whole lot of noise.

No decision stands alone. And neither does the action required to bring it to life.

Every time we make a decision to change something, we're also making decisions about what deserves our collective energy, what no longer does, and how we're going to redistribute that energy across the team. But if we don't collectively make room for that change, the energy easily gets pulled back to the current song.

And maybe that's the real work of collective decisioning.

Not just in deciding what we're going to do. But in collectively deciding what we're going to STOP doing, so we have the energy to actually DO it.

After all, the energy we invest in making a decision only creates value when it leads to something different happening.

So, the next time we finish a meeting feeling energized about a decision we've made, instead of asking "What's next?", let's ask...

"What are we going to stop putting our energy into, so we can start putting it into THIS?"

Now THAT sounds like the beginning of some collective momentum 🎶

Next
Next

Disagreement vs. Agreement: Which Creates More Momentum?